Jonathan Taylor Next Team Odds: Will Colts Trade JT to Giants, Vikings on NFL Trade Deadline Day?
Jonathan Taylor's future with the Indianapolis Colts remains uncertain heading into Tuesday's NFL trade deadline, with the New York Giants and New England Patriots among the leading potential destinations for the star running back. Can Taylor land a blockbuster trade despite his two-year, $44 million contract extension, or will Indianapolis retain its most valuable offensive player? Check out the latest Jonathan Taylor next team odds, trade rumors, and potential destinations for Tuesday, November 10.
Peter Alexis - November 10, 2026, 11:50 AM EST
4 Minute ReadJonathan Taylor Next Team Odds: Will Colts Trade Star Running Back Before Tuesday's Deadline?
Jonathan Taylor has emerged as one of the biggest names to watch ahead of Tuesday's NFL trade deadline, with the Indianapolis Colts considering additional roster moves following a disappointing 2-7 start. Taylor is priced at a 32% market-implied chance of remaining with Indianapolis, while the New York Giants sit at 24% and the New England Patriots have climbed to 17%.
The trade discussions have intensified after Indianapolis moved All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson to Seattle and defensive tackle DeForest Buckner to San Francisco, signaling a willingness to exchange established veterans for future draft capital. However, Taylor's recent two-year, $44 million extension and the Colts' substantial asking price have complicated negotiations, with the Giants reportedly withdrawing an earlier offer despite their significant need at running back.
Bet onJT's Next Team with Kalshi Here
Jonathan Taylor Next Team Odds
Jonathan Taylor Next Team Prediction Market
Indianapolis Colts: 32% Chance Bet on Jonathan Taylor's Next Team with Kalshi Here
Indianapolis holds the highest individual market price at 32%, climbing eight percentage points as the trade deadline approaches. The Colts have reportedly entertained several offers for Taylor but have been reluctant to accept anything short of a substantial package of draft picks, with the team initially seeking compensation comparable to San Francisco's 2022 trade for Christian McCaffrey.
Taylor remains one of the NFL's most productive running backs, recording 656 rushing yards and eight touchdowns through nine games this season. However, his recent workload has declined, including just eight carries against Jacksonville and 13 against Dallas, as the organization evaluates its direction following the departures of Nelson and Buckner.
His contract represents another significant consideration. Taylor signed a two-year, $44 million extension in August that runs through 2028 and includes $39 million in guarantees, although the acquiring team would not inherit the entire original contract value. Indianapolis would also retain certain salary-cap obligations, while Taylor's future compensation and the draft capital required to acquire him could discourage interested teams.
New York Giants: 24% Chance Bet on Jonathan Taylor's Next Team with Kalshi Here
The Giants are priced at 24%, down 10 percentage points following reports that the organization withdrew its previous trade offer for Taylor. New York reportedly proposed sending Indianapolis second- and fifth-round draft picks, but the Colts rejected the package while seeking a larger return, prompting the Giants to pull the offer before Sunday's games.
Despite the setback, New York remains one of the most significant potential suitors because of its injury situation and inconsistent rushing production. Tyrone Tracy Jr. is on injured reserve, while Cam Skattebo has dealt with a leg injury and ball-security concerns, leaving the Giants searching for additional stability in a backfield supporting their 5-2-1 start.
Head coach John Harbaugh has not completely ruled out revisiting negotiations, although he has emphasized that any acquisition must make sense beyond the remainder of the season. Taylor would provide an immediate upgrade to New York's offense and a proven option for its playoff push, but the combination of Indianapolis' asking price and his expensive contract remains the primary obstacle.
New England Patriots: 17% Chance Bet on Jonathan Taylor's Next Team with Kalshi Here
New England has climbed to a 17% market-implied chance of acquiring Taylor, gaining 15 percentage points during the latest trading period. The Patriots have emerged as an intriguing alternative to the Giants, particularly after injuries and availability concerns involving their running backs created additional uncertainty around the position.
Rhamondre Stevenson suffered a knee injury during Sunday's game, while rookie TreVeyon Henderson missed time because of illness. Taylor's experience and ability to handle a substantial rushing workload would provide another option for an offense built around quarterback Drake Maye, particularly if New England wants additional backfield depth entering the second half of the season.
However, the Patriots have not been linked to a confirmed formal offer, and their salary-cap situation could complicate any attempt to acquire Taylor. A deal would likely require financial adjustments alongside meaningful draft compensation, making New England's late market surge notable without establishing that negotiations are close to producing an agreement.
Why Jonathan Taylor's $44 Million Contract Could Prevent a Trade
Taylor's contract is one of the biggest complications surrounding the trade deadline discussions, particularly because the Colts committed substantial money to their star running back just three months ago. The two-year, $44 million extension carries an average annual value of $22 million in new money, placing Taylor among the NFL's highest-paid players at his position.
Although Indianapolis has already absorbed some of the financial commitment through his signing bonus, a new team would still inherit significant future compensation obligations. That makes the total investment considerably larger than the draft picks alone, particularly for teams already managing expensive quarterback contracts and limited salary-cap flexibility.
The Giants' decision to withdraw their reported offer illustrates the difficulty of finding a price acceptable to both teams. Indianapolis could prefer to wait for a stronger package, while interested clubs may believe that a second-round selection and additional compensation already represent a substantial investment for a 27-year-old running back.
Jonathan Taylor Trade Outlook: Will Colts Make a Deal on Tuesday?
The Colts face an important decision before the NFL trade deadline at 4 p.m. ET on Tuesday, November 10. Indianapolis has already demonstrated its willingness to move established players, but Taylor's production, contract and importance to the offense make his situation considerably different from those of other veterans.
The Giants remain the highest-priced outside destination at 24%, despite rescinding their previous offer, while New England has gained momentum in the market at 17%. Denver, Minnesota, Green Bay and Seattle have also generated varying levels of interest, creating the possibility of renewed negotiations if Indianapolis adjusts its asking price.
The next-team market has generated more than $3.9 million in trading volume, with the Colts' 32% price illustrating the uncertainty surrounding whether Taylor will leave Indianapolis. The contract covers his next team before December 1 rather than exclusively Tuesday's deadline, although November 10 represents the final opportunity for an in-season NFL trade.
With Taylor's future still unresolved, the biggest obstacle is whether another organization will meet Indianapolis' demands for both draft compensation and financial commitment. The Giants' withdrawn offer remains a significant development, but the final hours before the deadline will determine whether negotiations resume or Taylor stays with the Colts for the remainder of the 2026 season.
- Lean: Giants - 24% Chance Bet on the JT's Next Team with Kalshi Here
More of oddschecker
Affiliate Disclosure.
We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.
