Colts vs. Steelers Prediction, Betting Pick, Latest NFL Odds for Week 9
The Indianapolis Colts will put their win streak on the line when they visit a reeling Pittsburgh Steelers team on Sunday afternoon. Can Daniel Jones, Jonathan Taylor, and the red-hot Colts keep it rolling against Aaron Rodgers and the Steelers as slight road favorites? Let's take a look at this Colts vs. Steelers prediction for Week 9.
OC Staff - October 31, 2025, 9:45 AM EDT
6 Minute ReadColts vs. Steelers Prediction: Can Daniel Jones, Colts Continue Unlikely Winning Streak in Pittsburgh?
The AFC spotlight shines on Pittsburgh this week as the Steelers host the 7-1 Indianapolis Colts in what could be an early playoff preview. Both teams entered the season with new quarterbacks and high expectations, but their paths have started to diverge. The Colts have remained one of the league’s most consistent forces behind first-year starter Daniel Jones — nicknamed “Indiana Jones” for his surprising heroics — while the Steelers, led by veteran Aaron Rodgers, have cooled off after a hot start. Pittsburgh’s defense has let them down over the last two weeks, giving up nearly 70 combined points in consecutive losses that dropped them to 4-3.
Indianapolis has looked like a complete team through eight weeks, with head coach Shane Steichen’s aggressive approach keeping defenses off balance. The offense has been powered by Jonathan Taylor, who leads the NFL in rushing yards and touchdowns, finding the end zone 12 times already this season. His combination of patience, vision, and downhill burst has allowed the Colts to control games and open up opportunities for Jones to thrive in play-action. Behind a dominant offensive line, Indianapolis has won four straight and sits comfortably atop the AFC South standings.
The Steelers are 3.5-point underdogs at home — a rare spot for a Rodgers-led team — and face a crucial moment in their season. The defense, long the team’s calling card, must find a way to contain Taylor and force the Colts to rely on their young quarterback in a hostile environment. Rodgers, meanwhile, will look to recapture the spark that fueled Pittsburgh’s early success, particularly against an opportunistic Colts secondary that ranks among the league’s best in takeaways. Can the Steelers stop their skid and reassert themselves in the AFC playoff race, or will the Colts’ balance and momentum prove too much to slow down on Sunday?
Looking for advanced AI predictions and props to enhance your NFL betting? Try out oddschecker+ now on this limited time 7-day free trial!
Colts vs. Steelers Date, Time, and Where to Watch
- Date: Sunday, November 2, 2025
- Time: 1:00 PM ET
- How to Watch: CBS
Colts vs. Steelers Odds
Click here for the latest Colts vs. Steelers Odds
Colts vs. Steelers Prediction
The most compelling narrative will undoubtedly unfold in the aerial attacks, particularly how Aaron Rodgers and the Steelers' passing game contend with the Indianapolis Colts' formidable 8th-ranked pass defense. Rodgers, the perennial MVP candidate, is projected for 239.9 passing yards. While his talent is undeniable, historical data reveals a subtle yet significant dip in efficiency when facing top-10 pass defenses. In seven such encounters, Rodgers has averaged 221.9 passing yards with a passer rating of 92.4. The Colts' defense, allowing opponents a mere 8th-best QB Rating, presents a true test. Our model, however, sees a strong edge with a 5.9% EV on Rodgers exceeding his projected 222.5 passing yards at 1.91 (-110) odds, suggesting that even against a tough defense, his volume or efficiency might surprise.
On the other side of the ball, the spotlight shifts to Jonathan Taylor (IND RB1) against the Pittsburgh Steelers' 17th-ranked run defense. Taylor, a premier back in the league, is projected for 86.8 rushing yards on 18 carries. The Steelers' defense, while middle-of-the-pack against the run, faces a game-wrecker in Taylor. However, our analytics paint a different picture for this specific contest. The model has identified a significant edge with an 8.0% EV on Taylor rushing under 93.5 yards at 1.91 (-110) odds. This suggests that despite his reputation, the Steelers might find a way to contain him, or the game script could limit his opportunities, making his performance a critical swing factor in the game's overall flow.
Finally, the Colts' passing game, spearheaded by Daniel Jones (IND QB) and his top receiver Tyler Warren, will clash with the Pittsburgh Steelers' relentless 5th-ranked pass rush and 22nd-ranked pass defense. Jones, projected for 251.0 passing yards, faces a unique challenge: a defense that can pressure the quarterback at an elite level (5th in sacks) but has been susceptible to passing yardage (22nd in QB Rating Allowed). Interestingly, Jones' historical splits against top-10 pass defenses show him performing surprisingly well, averaging 244.4 YPG with a 97.6 passer rating in five such games. This hints at his ability to operate under pressure.
This dynamic opens a substantial opportunity for Tyler Warren, who is projected for 59.7 receiving yards. Our model is highly confident, flagging a significant edge with a 12.0% EV on Warren exceeding 56.5 receiving yards at 1.91 (-110) odds. This suggests that even as Jones navigates the Steelers' pass rush, Warren is poised to exploit weaknesses in their secondary, potentially becoming a primary target for quick passes or downfield opportunities.
Ultimately, while the individual battles for rushing supremacy will be hotly contested, the decisive factor in this high-stakes game will likely be Aaron Rodgers' ability to overcome the Colts' elite pass defense. If Rodgers can defy his historical trends against top-tier units and deliver on his projected over for passing yards, it will unlock Pittsburgh's offense and dictate the pace. Conversely, if the Colts' defense can stifle the legendary quarterback, it will put immense pressure on Pittsburgh's other offensive facets and swing momentum heavily in Indianapolis's favor.
Colts vs. Steelers Pick
- Pick: Under 50.5 Total Points (-110) Check out these best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook
More NFL Odds
Affiliate Disclosure.
We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.
