Top Anytime Touchdown Scorer Picks for Colts vs. Chiefs on Sunday Night Football - September 20th
The Indianapolis Colts visit the Kansas City Chiefs on Sunday Night Football at Arrowhead Stadium, with Indianapolis looking to rebound from a rough opener while Kansas City tries to build on a dominant Week 1 win. Can Jonathan Taylor, Alec Pierce and Rashee Rice turn their prominent offensive roles into touchdowns under the primetime lights? Check out these Colts vs. Chiefs 3 anytime touchdown scorer picks for Sunday, September 20.
Peter Alexis - September 20, 2026, 6:20 PM EDT
4 Minute ReadCan Jonathan Taylor, Alec Pierce Carry Colts with Scores on Sunday Night Football?
Indianapolis enters Sunday night needing a much cleaner performance after allowing 41 points to Baltimore, while Kansas City opened with an impressive 31-10 victory over Denver. The Colts still showed enough offensive life to create touchdown opportunities, particularly through Jonathan Taylor, while Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs immediately demonstrated how many different ways they can reach the end zone.
The card attacks three very different scoring profiles. Taylor carries the shortest number because of his massive goal-line role, Rice offers plus-money exposure to Mahomes and the Kansas City passing game, and Pierce provides the longest payout as a vertical receiver capable of cashing the bet on one explosive connection.
Colts vs. Chiefs Date, Time, Where to Watch
- Date: Sunday, September 20th, 2026
- Time: 8:20 PM ET
- Location: GEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium, Kansas City, Missouri
- How to Watch: NBC, Peacock
Colts vs. Chiefs Odds
- Spread: Indianapolis Colts +6 (-112), Kansas City Chiefs -6 (-108)
- Total Points: Over 47, Under 47
- Moneyline: Indianapolis Colts +220, Kansas City Chiefs -270
Click here for the latest Colts vs. Chiefs Odds
Colts vs. Chiefs Best Anytime Touchdown Scorer Picks
1. Alec Pierce Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+325) Check out the best odds at Bet365 Sportsbook
Pierce is the high-variance option, but +325 is exactly the type of price that makes his skill set attractive. He led Indianapolis receivers with four catches for 61 yards against Baltimore despite being somewhat limited, and he enters Sunday without an injury designation after managing a heel issue during the week.
The biggest reason to target Pierce is that he does not need sustained red-zone volume to score. He was the only NFL receiver to average more than 20 yards per catch last season, giving Daniel Jones a legitimate field-stretching weapon who can convert a single deep target into six points. That profile is particularly appealing when the market is offering better than 3-to-1 odds.
Pierce has scored in four of his last 10 games, while the model gives him a 39.56% touchdown probability compared to only 23.53% implied at +325. That produces 68.13% EV, easily the biggest value discrepancy of the three selections. The volatility is real, but the combination of explosive-play ability and a massive price makes Pierce an ideal touchdown sprinkle.
2. Jonathan Taylor Anytime Touchdown Scorer (-140) Check out the best odds at Fanatics Sportsbook
Taylor is the expensive option, but his Week 1 workload explains why the market is charging a premium. He rushed 19 times for 98 yards and two touchdowns against Baltimore while adding three catches for 23 yards, accounting for two of Indianapolis' three touchdowns in the loss.
That usage gives Taylor more touchdown paths than almost anyone else on the field. Indianapolis can feed him at the goal line, create scoring opportunities through longer runs and keep him involved as a receiver when Jones checks the ball down. Even if the Colts struggle to sustain drives at Arrowhead, Taylor remains the obvious candidate to finish them whenever Indianapolis gets close.
The projection is extremely aggressive, giving Taylor an 81.37% chance to score compared to the 58.33% implied probability at -140 for 39.49% EV. He has scored in five of his last 10 games and already enters Sunday with two touchdowns in one appearance this season. There is little mystery to the bet: Taylor is the centerpiece of the Colts offense and should again receive the first opportunity to finish drives.
3. Rashee Rice Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+170) Check out the best odds at Fanatics Sportsbook
Rice did not need much volume to score in Kansas City's opener. He finished with only two receptions for 19 yards, but one was a 13-yard touchdown on a designed bubble screen from Mahomes, immediately showing that Andy Reid is still willing to manufacture scoring opportunities for him rather than relying exclusively on traditional downfield targets.
There is also encouraging history against Indianapolis even though he did not score in last season's meeting. Rice caught eight passes for 141 yards against the Colts, demonstrating that this matchup can generate substantial volume for him. Add in five touchdowns across eight games last season, and the broader scoring profile is considerably stronger than the two-catch Week 1 box score suggests.
Rice has reached the end zone in five of his last 10 games, and the model gives him a 43.75% touchdown probability against a 37.04% implied probability at +170. That creates 18.13% EV while offering much more attractive odds than the shortest-priced Kansas City options. With Mahomes already finding him for a designed score in Week 1, Rice is a strong plus-money way to get exposure to the Chiefs offense.
More Football Odds
Affiliate Disclosure.
We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.
