Brewers vs. Padres Best Bets: 3 Top Props for NLDS Game 3 on Tuesday Night
The Brewers and Padres shift to Petco Park for Game 3 on Tuesday with Milwaukee one win away from completing a sweep after taking both games at home. Can Brice Turang, Dustin May and San Diego's lineup determine whether the Brewers advance or the Padres extend their season? Check out these Padres vs. Brewers 5 best bets for Tuesday, October 6.
Peter Alexis - October 6, 2026, 7:30 PM EDT
3 Minute ReadBrewers vs. Padres Prediction: Targeting Dustin May, Brice Turang in Tuesday's Top Props for NLDS Game 3
Milwaukee grabbed a 2-0 series lead with a dramatic 4-3 win in Game 2, as Jackson Chourio delivered a two-out, two-run walk-off single in the ninth inning. The Brewers have now won the first two games by a combined two runs, while San Diego returns home needing three straight victories to keep its postseason run alive.
Game 3 presents another tight betting setup after consecutive one-run finishes. The five selections span a Dustin May strikeout prop, the Milwaukee moneyline, two Brice Turang markets and a game total that again expects a relatively low-scoring environment.
Brewers vs. Padres Date, Time, and Where to Watch
- Date: Tuesday, October 6th, 2026
- Time: 9:30 PM ET
- How to Watch: FS1
Brewers vs. Padres Odds
Click here for complete MLB Playoffs Odds
Brewers vs. Padres 3 Best Bets Breakdown for NLDS Game 3
1. Dustin May Over 3.5 Strikeouts (+146) Check out the best odds at FanDuel Sportsbook
Dustin May presents a significant value opportunity in the strikeout market at +146 odds. While May has averaged just 3.4 innings over his last five starts, the Q4 AI model projects him to record 4.65 strikeouts in this matchup. His underlying metrics remain encouraging, including an 8.90 K/9 rate across 145.2 innings this season and 22 strikeouts in his most recent 17 frames.
The model assigns a 68.2% probability that May eclipses the 3.5 strikeout line, creating an outsized expected value of +67.9%. Against a Padres lineup that can be susceptible to high-velocity stuff, May’s ability to generate swings and misses makes this a top-tier value play.
2. Milwaukee Brewers Moneyline (+115) Check out the best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook
The Brewers enter this contest as an attractive underdog at +115. Milwaukee has been one of the most consistent teams in baseball this season, posting a 103-59 record behind an offense that generated 839 runs and a .258 team batting average. The Q4 AI model strongly disagrees with the market's underdog pricing, assigning the Brewers a 67.4% win probability and a projected 4.71 runs.
While Nick Pivetta has been effective for San Diego, he averages only 4.4 innings per start, which should force the Padres to rely on their bullpen early. Given the Brewers' offensive efficiency and the model's high win probability, this moneyline selection offers a substantial +44.9% expected value.
3. Brice Turang Over 0.5 RBIs (+200) Check out the best odds at BetMGM Sportsbook
Brice Turang has emerged as a primary catalyst for the Brewers' offense, and his RBI prop at +200 offers a massive +69.7% expected value. The Q4 model forecasts Turang with an expected 0.834 RBIs, the highest projection among all Milwaukee hitters for this game. Turang’s ability to reach base and drive in runs was evident in his regular-season slash line, featuring a .369 OBP and .454 slugging percentage.
While Padres starter Nick Pivetta holds an elite 10.90 K/9, the Brewers are still projected to score 4.71 runs overall. With a 56.6% AI-implied probability of recording at least one RBI, Turang is well-positioned to capitalize on run-scoring opportunities in this postseason environment.
4. Under 7.0 (+105) Check out the best odds at Caesars Sportsbook
A total of 7.0 runs is a tight line, but the Under at +105 offers value based on the elite relief options available for both clubs. San Diego’s Mason Miller (1.67 ERA, 129 Ks in 70 IP) and Milwaukee’s Trevor Megill (2.63 ERA, 0.89 WHIP) anchor two of the best bullpens in the league, capable of shutting down scoring in the late innings.
Additionally, Nick Pivetta has been dominant lately, posting a 1.80 ERA over his last five starts and a 2.17 FIP on the season. The Q4 AI model assigns a 52.4% probability to the Under, resulting in a +7.4% expected value. In a high-stakes postseason matchup, expect pitching to lead the way.
5. Brice Turang Over 0.5 Doubles (+414) Check out the best odds at FanDuel Sportsbook
For bettors looking for a high-upside prop, Brice Turang to record a double at +414 provides significant +48.2% expected value. The Q4 AI model identifies Turang as the top double threat in this game, projecting an expected double score of 0.340—higher than any other player on either roster. Turang demonstrated consistent gap-to-gap power throughout the season, finishing with 164 games played and a .454 slugging percentage.
While doubles props are inherently volatile due to outfield dimensions and bounces, the discrepancy between the 28.8% model-implied probability and the market odds makes this a mathematically sound long-shot play for those seeking value on a specific extra-base hit outcome.
More MLB Odds
