First Four Best Bets: College Basketball Player Prop Parlay for Wednesday's First Four Matchups
The March Madness First Four will get continue in Dayton on Wednesday night, with the lasto two matchups as Miami (OH) vs. SMU and Prairie View A&M vs. Lehigh. Will Dontae Horne and Peter Suder step up? McBets is targeting both in his First Four Bets for Wednesday, March 18th.
McBets - March 18, 2026, 9:18 AM EDT
4 Minute ReadFirst Four CBB Parlay Picks: Can Dontae Horne, Peter Suder Step Up in Wednesday's First Four in Dayton?
This two-leg parlay comes from two separate play-in games, and both spots share the same foundation: teams fighting for a March Madness bid lean heavily on their top scorers. In win-or-go-home environments, minutes tighten, shot volume concentrates, and primary options rarely leave the floor. That’s exactly the setup here.
Looking for advanced AI predictions and props to enhance your College Basketball betting? Try out oddschecker+ now on this limited time 7-day free trial!
Wednesday CBB Prop Parlay - March 18th First Four
Leg 1: Dontae Horne 20+ Points
Dontae Horne 20+ Points anchors the first leg, and his recent stretch shows just how dominant his offensive role has become. Horne has cleared this number in 8 of his past 10 games, averaging 25.2 points per contest during that span. The production is driven by elite usage — he’s logging 38.9 minutes per game and taking 20 field goal attempts per game over his last 10, numbers that reflect a true centerpiece scorer.
The matchup against Lehigh supports continued production. Lehigh allows 74.8 points per game, creating a neutral-to-favorable scoring environment for high-volume players. More importantly, this is a game where Prairie View’s season is on the line. In these situations, teams don’t diversify offense — they lean into what works. That means heavy touches, full minutes, and a green light for Horne throughout.
Click here for the latest Prairie View A&M vs. Lehigh Odds
Leg 2: Peter Suder 10+ Points
The second leg turns to Peter Suder 10+ Points, another player whose role has been extremely stable. Suder has cleared this line in 15 straight games, averaging 17.3 points per game during that run. His scoring consistency stands out, especially for a number set this low relative to his average.
Usage backs it up. Suder is playing 32.6 minutes per game and taking 10.6 field goal attempts over his past 10 games, providing a reliable baseline for scoring. He doesn’t need a spike performance — just his normal involvement to clear double digits.
The matchup against SMU adds another layer. SMU allows 78.4 points per game and has struggled defensively against guards recently, with 4 of the past 5 opposing backcourt players clearing this scoring line. That trend points to a defense that has had trouble containing perimeter scorers with steady roles.
With an 11-seed on the line, Miami Ohio is unlikely to reduce Suder’s minutes or role. In tournament settings, players with consistent production tend to see their usage maintained or even increased — not scaled back.
Click here for the latest Miami (OH) vs. SMU Odds
First Four CBB Parlay Picks (-112) Check out these best odds on FanDuel Sportsbook
- Dontae Horne 20+ Points
- Peter Suder 10+ Points
When you combine Horne’s elite scoring volume in a must-win setting with Suder’s extended consistency and favorable matchup, this parlay leans on usage concentration and game importancerather than variance. Both players are already producing above these numbers — and in elimination games, that production tends to hold.
Two stars. Two elimination games.
And two roles that only grow when everything’s on the line.
More College Basketball Odds
Affiliate Disclosure.
We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.
