Top Anytime Touchdown Scorer Picks for Bills vs. Rams on Monday Night Football
The Buffalo Bills visit the Los Angeles Rams on Monday Night Football in a potential shootout between two offenses capable of producing points in bunches at SoFi Stadium. Can Josh Allen, Matthew Stafford and their red-zone playmakers turn another high-total matchup into a touchdown-heavy night? Check out these Bills vs. Rams 5 anytime touchdown scorer picks for Monday, October 12.
Peter Alexis - October 12, 2026, 6:45 PM EDT
4 Minute ReadWill James Cook, Davante Adams and More Find the End Zone on Monday Night Football?
Bills-Rams carries one of the strongest touchdown environments of Week 5, with a total around 54.5 and a recent history that includes Los Angeles’ wild 44-42 win over Buffalo at SoFi Stadium in 2024. Buffalo enters 3-1 and Los Angeles 2-2, leaving both offenses with plenty of incentive to remain aggressive rather than settling into a conservative primetime game script.
The card reflects that environment by mixing primary scorers with two substantially longer-priced backfield options. Buffalo’s injuries at wide receiver could also concentrate touches elsewhere, while the Rams have enough offensive balance to create several legitimate touchdown paths if this game develops anywhere near its projected scoring level.
Bills vs. Rams Date, Time, Where to Watch
- Date: Monday, October 12, 2026
- Time: 8:15 PM ET
- Location: SoFi Stadium, Inglewood, California
- How to Watch: ESPN
Bills vs. Rams Odds
- Spread: Buffalo Bills +3.5, Los Angeles Rams -3.5
- Total Points: Over 55.5, Under 55.5
- Moneyline: Buffalo Bills +154, Los Angeles Rams -185
Click here for the latest Bills vs. Rams Odds
Bills vs. Rams Best Anytime Touchdown Scorer Picks
1. James Cook Anytime Touchdown Scorer (-110) Check out the best odds at BetMGM Sportsbook
Cook has become the clearest non-quarterback touchdown option in Buffalo’s offense. He has scored in three consecutive games while rushing for 421 yards on 70 carries through four weeks, an excellent 6.0 yards per attempt. His workload has also climbed when Buffalo has needed to control games, including 21 carries against Detroit and 24 against the Chargers.
The only persistent danger is Allen taking the most valuable goal-line carries himself. Even with that competition, Cook has continued converting scoring opportunities, and his ability to create explosive runs means he does not have to receive the ball from the one-yard line to cash.
At -110, the price remains reasonable for a feature back riding a three-game touchdown streak in a game projected to produce more than seven combined touchdowns. If Buffalo reaches the 30-point range again, Cook should have multiple realistic paths to account for one.
2. Dalton Kincaid Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+200) Check out the best odds at Fanatics Sportsbook
Kincaid is the preferred plus-money Buffalo receiving option, especially with Joshua Palmer ruled out and DJ Moore entering Monday with a shoulder issue. A thinner receiver rotation can naturally push additional high-leverage work toward a tight end who already demonstrated major early-season receiving upside.
Kincaid has 15 receptions for 270 yards through four games, including 130 yards in the opener and 95 yards with a touchdown against Detroit. The last two weeks have been quieter, but the underlying ability has not disappeared, and his 18.0 yards per reception this season shows he is offering far more than simple underneath check.
At +200, there is enough payout to attack a bounce-back opportunity. Allen has consistently trusted tight ends when defenses compress near the goal line, and Kincaid only needs one favorable matchup against a linebacker or safety to turn a relatively modest target total into a touchdown.
3. Davante Adams Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+100) Check out the best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook
Adams has only scored in one of four games this season, but that understates how dangerous his role remains. He has 22 catches for 390 yards, including a massive eight-catch, 195-yard, two-touchdown performance against the Giants and another 137-yard game at Denver.
The bigger reason to stay aggressive is his established scoring profile with Los Angeles. Adams led the NFL with 14 receiving touchdowns last season, showing how heavily Sean McVay and Stafford trust him around the end zone. His current two-touchdown total looks relatively modest compared to the volume and explosive production he has generated through four games.
Even money is a strong price for an elite red-zone receiver in the highest-total game on Monday’s board. Adams does not need 150 yards again to cash. One isolated matchup from inside the 10 can be enough.
4. Ty Johnson Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+750) Check out the best odds at FanDuel Sportsbook
Johnson is the true Buffalo lottery-ticket play at +750. His rushing role is almost nonexistent behind Cook, with only one carry this season, but Buffalo has continued using him as a receiving back in passing situations. He caught four passes for 50 yards against the Chargers and added two receptions against New England.
That specialized role is exactly why the price is appealing in a potential shootout. Johnson does not need to steal conventional goal-line carries from Cook or Allen. His path is a screen, angle route or checkdown that catches Los Angeles in pressure and gives him space to finish a play.
The historical receiving production also shows that this is not an impossible route to six points. Johnson scored five receiving touchdowns across the previous two seasons with Buffalo despite operating as a reserve. At 7.5-to-1, the bet is built around one specialized touch landing in exactly the right spot rather than expecting meaningful volume.
5. Blake Corum Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+300) Check out the best odds at Caesars Sportsbook
Corum provides the Rams version of the secondary-back touchdown angle, but with a significantly larger rushing workload than Johnson. He has already handled 33 carries for 162 yards this season, averaging 4.9 yards per attempt, despite remaining behind Kyren Williams in the backfield hierarchy.
The touchdown is the one thing missing. Corum has not scored through four games, but he has received double-digit carries once and continues to rotate into an offense that should spend plenty of time in Buffalo territory Monday night. His 12-carry, 79-yard performance against the Giants showed that McVay is willing to expand the role when the game script permits it.
At +300, the bet does not require Corum to overtake Williams. Los Angeles can score four touchdowns and still create enough backfield opportunities for the No. 2 runner to steal one series or short-yardage possession. In a 54.5-point environment, that makes the 3-to-1 number worth taking as the final upside piece of the card.
More Football Odds
Affiliate Disclosure.
We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.
