NFL Draft First Overall Pick Odds: Arch Manning Leads Crowded Field of Quarterback Contenders

Can Anyone Top Arch Manning in NFL First Draft Pick Race?

The race to become the first pick in the 2027 NFL Draft is beginning to take shape, with Arch Manning leading the market at +225. Dante Moore and CJ Carr share the next spot at +500, while Darian Mensah and Trinidad Chambliss have strengthened their profiles with productive starts to the college season.

Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith adds another dimension to a quarterback-heavy board. Early production matters, but this market ultimately depends on NFL evaluations, which players declare and the needs of the team holding the first selection. An outstanding college season can strengthen a prospect’s case without necessarily making him the most likely No. 1 pick.

2026 NFL Draft First Pick Odds

Click here for complete NFL Odds

2026 NFL Draft First Pick Odds Breakdown

Arch Manning: +225 Check out these best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook

Manning remains the favorite despite an uneven opening stretch. He began with 305 passing yards and four touchdowns against Texas State, then helped Texas rally for a 24–23 victory over Ohio State despite finishing with 195 yards, one touchdown and an interception. Two touchdown passes followed in a 30–6 win over UTSA, although the offense lacked consistency.

His path to the first selection rests on pairing his physical ability with more reliable execution against SEC defenses. The comeback against Ohio State helped, but sustained accuracy and decision-making will matter more than a single signature victory.

Dante Moore: +500 Check out these best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook

Moore responded to Oregon’s upset loss at Oklahoma State by completing 19 of 23 passes for 280 yards and four touchdowns in an 84–0 win over Portland State. That was an efficient rebound, although dominating an overmatched opponent does not resolve the questions raised the previous week.

His first-pick case needs stronger evidence against defenses that can disrupt his timing and force adjustments. At +500, Moore remains a major challenger, with conference play providing the opportunity to show that his passing production can hold up when the pocket becomes less comfortable.

CJ Carr: +500 Check out these best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook

Carr has opened with the kind of efficiency that keeps a quarterback firmly in the draft conversation. Through three games, he has completed 72.6% of his passes for 726 yards, six touchdowns and no interceptions. His four-touchdown performance against Rice stands out, and Notre Dame followed with a 27–10 win over Michigan State.

Protecting the ball is a strong foundation, but reaching the top of this class will require more than avoiding mistakes. Carr needs to maintain that efficiency while showing he can create difficult completions and carry the offense when opponents take away its preferred options.

Darian Mensah: +700 Check out these best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook

Mensah immediately attracted attention at Miami with 401 passing yards and five touchdowns in a 45–6 opening win over Stanford. He followed that early statement with another highly accurate performance against Wake Forest, completing 30 of 34 passes for 220 yards and three touchdowns in a 33–20 victory.

His start supports a rising profile, but the next question is how that production translates against stronger opposition. To challenge for the first selection, Mensah needs to complement his command of Miami’s offense with evidence that he can consistently deliver under pressure and attack tighter throwing windows.

Jeremiah Smith: +900 Check out these best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook

Smith has started with 400 receiving yards through three games, including five catches for 85 yards in Ohio State’s 59–3 win over Kent State. That performance also moved him into first place on the school’s career receiving yardage list, reinforcing how productive he has been throughout his college career. His challenge in this market is positional value.

Even if Smith earns the highest overall evaluation, a quarterback-needy team could select a passer or trade the pick to another club seeking one. His clearest route requires an exceptional season and a draft order that favors adding a premier receiving weapon.

Trinidad Chambliss: +1000 Check out these best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook

Chambliss supplied one of the strongest early statements among these contenders by throwing for 363 yards and two touchdowns, with another score on the ground, in Ole Miss’ 32–24 victory over LSU. Through three games, he has completed 70% of his passes for 924 yards, seven touchdowns and two interceptions.

The LSU performance carries particular weight because it came against a ranked SEC opponent. His route to the first pick requires making that level of play repeatable, combining his ability to extend plays with consistent pocket execution throughout the conference schedule.

2027 NFL Draft First Pick Betting Outlook

Manning holds the shortest price, but the opening weeks have left room for competition. Carr’s efficiency, Moore’s rebound and the strong starts from Mensah and Chambliss give this quarterback class several developing storylines. Smith has already supplied exceptional production, although his first-pick chances depend more heavily on team needs.

The distinction between the best college player and the first NFL selection remains central. Conference play should provide a better test of these prospects, particularly their response to pressure and stronger competition. For now, Manning leads the board, but +225 reflects a competitive race with substantial room for movement.

More NFL Odds

• Click here for complete NFL Odds
• Looking for more NFL analysis, check out our preseason insights
• Can the Bills finally win it all with a new coach? See the full Super Bowl Odds