Best Anytime Touchdown Scorer Picks Week 3: Targeting Players Who Haven't Scored Yet This Season
NFL Week 3 features several strong anytime touchdown opportunities across Sunday's daytime slate, including a high-total international game and multiple division matchups. Can established red-zone weapons and high-volume playmakers convert their early-season usage into touchdowns? Check out these NFL Week 3 5 anytime touchdown scorer picks for Sunday, September 27.
Peter Alexis - September 27, 2026, 12:15 PM EDT
4 Minute ReadWill George Pickens, Mark Andrews Finally Score in NFL Week 3?
This five-player card mixes proven goal-line backs with pass-catchers whose early-season usage has not yet fully translated into touchdowns. The Ravens-Cowboys game in Brazil brings one of the highest totals on the slate, while several of the other selections are built around players dominating touches or targets inside offenses that consistently run through them.
There is also value in attacking players who have produced everywhere except the end zone through two weeks. George Pickens, Mark Andrews and Tetairoa McMillan are all still looking for their first touchdowns of 2026 despite meaningful offensive involvement, while Chase Brown and Jonathan Taylor provide much clearer rushing paths near the goal line.
Click here for the latest NFL Odds
1. Chase Brown Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+125)
1. George Pickens Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+160) Check out the best odds at Fanatics Sportsbook
Pickens has not scored through his first two games, but Dallas has kept him heavily involved with 14 targets and nine receptions. The yardage has been modest so far, but the volume matters for a receiver who scored nine regular-season touchdowns last year and has already established himself as one of Dak Prescott's primary options.
The matchup with Baltimore also creates one of the best scoring environments of the week. The Cowboys and Ravens head to Brazil with a total north of 50 points, and Dallas may have to throw aggressively if Lamar Jackson and the Baltimore offense push the pace. That gives Pickens more opportunities to attack downfield and around the end zone.
At +160, the bet is essentially a wager that the early touchdown drought corrects in a game where Dallas should need points. Pickens has the size and contested-catch ability to remain dangerous even without massive separation, making him an appealing plus-money scorer in the highest-upside game environment on this card.
2. Mark Andrews Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+125) Check out the best odds at FanDuel Sportsbook
Andrews is another established touchdown producer still waiting for his first score of the season. He has caught 10 passes for 98 yards through two games, including six receptions last week, so the lack of touchdowns has not come from disappearing from Baltimore's passing offense.
The circumstances are particularly attractive with Zay Flowers sidelined. Lamar Jackson should continue leaning on Andrews, especially in high-leverage situations where his size and familiarity with Jackson make him one of Baltimore's most natural red-zone targets. Andrews has 56 career receiving touchdowns and has consistently been one of the league's most dangerous scoring tight ends.
Dallas-Baltimore's massive total only strengthens the case. The Ravens should create multiple trips inside Cowboys territory, and +125 is a playable price for a tight end whose role should expand near the goal line with one of Baltimore's primary receiving weapons unavailable.
3. Tetairoa McMillan Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+200) Check out the best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook
McMillan has been one of Carolina's most productive offensive players without finding the end zone. He has 10 catches for 176 yards through two games, including five receptions for 101 yards in the Panthers' 34-3 win over Atlanta last week.
The usage suggests the touchdown should eventually follow. McMillan has commanded roughly 23% of Carolina's targets, owns three red-zone targets and five deep targets, and drew an end-zone look against Atlanta that was knocked away. Xavier Legette being out also removes another receiver from the rotation and should help consolidate valuable opportunities around McMillan.
At +200, the market is offering 2-to-1 on Carolina's top perimeter receiving threat despite his combination of target share, downfield usage and red-zone involvement. His 6-foot-4 frame gives Bryce Young an obvious option when the field compresses, making this a strong spot to target McMillan's first touchdown of the season.
4. Chase Brown Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+105) Check out the best odds at Fanatics Sportsbook
Brown offers one of the clearest volume-based cases on the card. He has already handled 36 carries through Cincinnati's first two games while adding eight receptions, giving him 44 offensive touches and a major role in an offense that has started 2-0.
He scored in the opener against Tampa Bay and then received 20 carries for 80 yards in Cincinnati's 20-6 win over Houston. Even without a touchdown last week, that workload is exactly what is wanted from an anytime scorer. Brown does not need to rely on a handful of targets or one explosive play because Cincinnati consistently puts the ball in his hands.
The Bengals-Steelers rivalry can produce tighter, more physical games, which may actually help Brown's touchdown case. Cincinnati can lean on him near the goal line and use the running game to finish drives rather than asking Joe Burrow to force throws into condensed coverage. Getting essentially even money on a back receiving around 20 touches per game is attractive.
5. Jonathan Taylor Anytime Touchdown Scorer (-145) Check out the best odds at Fanatics Sportsbook
Taylor is the only odds-on selection, but his early-season touchdown role has been impossible to ignore. He has scored twice in each of Indianapolis' first two games, giving him four rushing touchdowns already while operating as the centerpiece of the Colts offense.
The workload has been just as impressive as the scoring. Taylor rushed 19 times for 98 yards against Baltimore before carrying 24 times for 92 yards and two more touchdowns against Kansas City, finishing the Chiefs game with 132 total yards. Indianapolis has shown no hesitation about feeding him when drives reach scoring range.
Houston has surrendered two rushing touchdowns through two games, and Taylor remains the most obvious player Indianapolis can use to attack that area. The -145 price is heavier than the rest of the card, but four touchdowns in two games combined with consecutive workloads approaching or exceeding 20 carries makes Taylor the safest volume-driven scorer among these five selections.
More Football Odds
Affiliate Disclosure.
We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.
