New York City FC vs Atlanta United Lineups, Prediction, Betting Picks & Odds

New York City FC vs Atlanta United Game Preview

New York City FC host Atlanta United at Citi Field, and the betting odds make the hosts -125 (Polymarket) favorites despite a slump that refuses to end.

NYCFC have failed to win their last six games in Major League Soccer, though a stoppage-time point at Orlando City kept them alive in the race for ninth.

Atlanta United's faint hopes of a late charge have gone up in flames, and the visitors have dropped to 14th in the Eastern Conference standings.

The head-to-head backs the hosts. New York City FC are undefeated in 12 of their last 13 games against Atlanta United in all competitions.

New York City FC vs Atlanta United Recent Results

New York City FC have won one of their last 10 games, and their last outing summed it up: a 2-2 tie at Orlando City, salvaged only by Jonathan Shore's goal off the bench deep into stoppage time. Alonso Martínez also scored, but this attack needs more than late rescues to climb the standings.

Atlanta United have suffered three defeats in their last four games, the latest a 3-2 home loss to Chicago Fire FC despite goals from Tomás Jacob and Breel Embolo. Embolo remains the focal point up top, while Miguel Almirón carries the creative load. A defense that keeps springing leaks is no way to chase a playoff spot.

New York City FC vs Atlanta United Lineups & Team News

Injuries & Suspensions

New York City FC: Matt Freese (Injured/doubtful), M. Moralez (Injured/out), K. Parks (Injured/out), D. Baiera (Injured/out), K. Trewin (Injured/out), A. Farnós (Injured/out)

Atlanta United: W. Reilly (Injured/out)

New York City FC

The lineup picture hinges on a fitness check in goal. Matt Freese picked up an injury against Orlando City, and Tomas Romero steps in if he is not ruled fit. Pascal Jensen could recall Jonathan Shore in midfield after his goal off the bench last time out, while Maxi Moralez and Keaton Parks headline a five-man injury list.

Atlanta United

Will Reilly is the away side's only injury concern for the trip to New York, so Gerardo Martino has close to a full deck. Martino could bring Fafà Picault into the attack alongside Breel Embolo and Miguel Almirón.

New York City FC vs Atlanta United Predicted Lineup

New York City FC

Formation: 4-2-3-1 (probable)

Predicted Starting Lineup: T. Romero; T. Gray, T. Martins, J. Sands, K. O'Toole; J. Shore, A. Perea; A. Ojeda, N. F. Mercau, H. Wolf; A. Martínez (probable)

Atlanta United

Formation: 4-3-3 (probable)

Predicted Starting Lineup: L. Hoyos; T. Jacob, P. Díaz, J. Alonso, E. Báez; G. Galoppo, M. Amaro, J. Fortune; M. Almirón, B. Embolo, F. Picault (probable)

New York City FC vs Atlanta United Key Stats & Game Facts

• New York City FC have scored 2+ goals in 4 out of 4 games against Atlanta United in Major League Soccer.
• Atlanta United have had 5+ shots on target in 5 out of 6 games against New York City FC in Major League Soccer.
• Nicolás Fernández Mercau has won 3+ fouls in 9 of his last 10 appearances in Major League Soccer.
• Saba Lobjanidze has attempted 4+ shots in 4 of his last 5 appearances in Major League Soccer.
• Miguel Almirón has scored or assisted in 4 of his last 6 appearances against New York City FC in Major League Soccer.

New York City FC vs Atlanta United Prediction & Best Picks

Our Prediction

Our prediction here is a 2-1 home win. The winless run is ugly, but NYCFC love a through ball and Atlanta struggle to defend exactly that, while the visitors are also wasteful when it comes to finishing scoring opportunities. That mismatch decides it, and Atlanta at +350 (Polymarket) are clear underdogs for good reason.

Best Picks

Over 2.5 goals in the Total Goals Over/Under market. Both teams have a record of scoring freely in this fixture. This first pick lives in the Total Goals Over/Under market. New York City FC have seen over 2.5 goals in their last 4 games against Atlanta United in all competitions, and the hosts are weak at protecting a lead, so one goal rarely settles this matchup. Our projected total of 3.16 goals sits comfortably above the line.

Yes in the Both Teams To Score market. Both sides have scored in five of the last six meetings, including a 2-2 draw last time out. The second selection sits in that same scoring-focused space, just a different market. We put the probability of both sides finding the net at 60.9%, above the implied probability of the price, and it fits our projected 2-1 scoreline. Atlanta love a long shot, so even a wasteful attack can find a way past a home side that keeps leaking goals.

New York City FC vs Atlanta United Same Game Parlay

This four-leg Same Game Parlay combines Miguel Almirón shots, Breel Embolo on target, a Keaton Parks card and a high-scoring total.

Miguel Almirón Over 2.5 shots: he has attempted 3+ shots in 5 of his last 6 appearances in Major League Soccer, working the right flank where NYCFC struggle to defend.

Breel Embolo Over 0.5 shots on target: the striker has recorded 1+ shots on target in 7 of his last 9 appearances in Major League Soccer, and he scored last time out.

Keaton Parks to be shown a card: proceed with caution here. Parks is listed among New York City FC's injured players, so this leg only works if he is cleared to feature.

Over 3.5 total goals: there have been 4+ goals in 4 of the last 4 meetings between these clubs in Major League Soccer, and Atlanta's leaky defense keeps that door open.

Shop around and lock in the strongest number for this parlay using Oddschecker's Exclusive Same Game Parlay Comparison Tool.

Same Game Parlay odds correct at time of publishing.

New York City FC vs Atlanta United Talking Points

The big question is whether NYCFC can keep Miguel Almirón quiet. The playmaker leads Atlanta with 14 goal contributions, and he operates on the right, which is right where the hosts struggle to defend attacks down the wings. At the other end, NYCFC's habit of playing through balls goes straight at a soft spot in Atlanta's back line. Across the last six meetings each side has won once and four have ended in ties, so a home win here would break a stubborn pattern.

New York City FC vs Atlanta United Predictions FAQs

When is the New York City FC vs Atlanta United MLS game?

The game is on Wednesday, October 28, 2026, with kickoff at 7:30 PM ET / 4:30 PM PT.

Where is New York City FC vs Atlanta United being played?

The game is being played at Citi Field in New York.

Who are the probable starters for New York City FC vs Atlanta United?

New York City FC are projected in a 4-2-3-1 with T. Romero, K. O'Toole, J. Sands, T. Martins, T. Gray, J. Shore, A. Perea, H. Wolf, N. F. Mercau, A. Ojeda and A. Martínez. Atlanta United are projected in a 4-3-3 with L. Hoyos, E. Báez, J. Alonso, P. Díaz, T. Jacob, G. Galoppo, M. Amaro, J. Fortune, F. Picault, B. Embolo and M. Almirón.

How have New York City FC and Atlanta United been performing recently?

New York City FC have failed to win their last 6 Major League Soccer games, while Atlanta United have suffered three defeats in their last four games. New York City FC have also been undefeated in 12 of their last 13 games against Atlanta United in all competitions.

Affiliate Disclosure

We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.

Please gamble responsibly. 21+.