Cleveland Cavaliers vs. New York Knicks Prediction, Betting Pick, Latest NBA Playoffs Game 2 Odds
The Cleveland Cavaliers head back to Madison Square Garden on Thursday looking to wipe one of the most painful losses of the playoff era out of their heads. New York erased a 22-point fourth-quarter deficit to steal Game 1 in overtime, and Vegas has the Knicks favored by a touchdown to make it 2-0. Let's check out the odds and best bet for this Cleveland Cavaliers vs. New York Knicks prediction on May 21, 2026.
OC Staff - May 21, 2026, 6:00 PM EDT
3 Minute ReadCleveland Cavaliers vs. New York Knicks Prediction: Odds, Best Bet, and Best Prop for Game 2
Jalen Brunson dropped 38 points in Game 1, ran the entire fourth quarter through James Harden in iso, and turned a Cleveland lead that looked impenetrable into an overtime loss for the Cavs. Cleveland scored just 3 points in the five-minute overtime, which is the kind of cold spell that would have me putting down 2K and walking outside. The Cavs shot 22% over the back half of the fourth and watched their lead evaporate one missed jumper at a time. They were a so close to stealing a game, and now they're down in a series they probably had circled as their easiest path to a Finals appearance.
New York opens as a 6.5-point home favorite with the total parked at 214.5, and the Knicks moneyline sits in the -240 range depending on the book. Cleveland +6.5 at +198 still gets some moneyline respect, mostly because Brunson played 46 minutes and is closer to a load-management candidate than fans want to admit. The cleaner angle lives in Brunson's points prop with Harden still on the floor, since the Knicks would have to torch Cleveland from deep to really blow this thing open. The Knicks went 6-of-21 from three in Game 1 and still won by 11, which tells you where the math gets ugly for the Cavs if the shooting evens out.
Cleveland Cavaliers vs. New York Knicks Recent Results
Coach Kenny Atkinson had the Cavs locked in as the 4-seed at 52-30 during the regular season. They eliminated the Raptors in seven before knocking off the top-seeded Pistons in another seven-game series capped by a Game 7 blowout in Detroit. Donovan Mitchell has been the engine of the playoff run, averaging 25.9 points per game on heavy usage. He had 29 points with six steals in Game 1 before Anunoby smothered him scoreless over the final 13 minutes. Evan Mobley quietly stuffed the box score with 15 points and 14 rebounds, doing big-man center stuff at a level the Knicks aren't really built to deal with. Harden is the wild card and the giant red flag of this whole series. He put up 15 points with six turnovers and a defensive performance that looked closer to a traffic cone than a starting guard.
New York rolled in as the 3-seed and currently sits on an eight-game win streak heading into Game 2. The Knicks knocked out the Hawks in six during round one before sweeping Philly in round two. Brunson has carried this team through every series, posting 28.4 points per game across 11 playoff appearances on 48.5% shooting. Mikal Bridges added 18 in Game 1 and looks healthy after the slog of round two. OG Anunoby returned from a hamstring strain to drop 13 timely points and lock up Mitchell down the stretch. Karl-Anthony Towns put up his usual 18-and-9, but late-game foul trouble nearly cost the Knicks the comeback. New York's eight straight wins all came at home, where they've been the toughest cover in the Conference Finals bracket.
Cleveland Cavaliers vs. New York Knicks Head To Head
New York won their regular-season series 2-1. Brunson dropped 23, 34, and 20 points across his three regular-season games against the Cavs. Mitchell averaged 27.0 against the Knicks during the year. The two of them are basically guaranteed to combine for 60-plus a night when fully engaged. None of those regular-season matchups featured the playoff-tightened rotations either team is running now.
These two franchises met in the first round of the 2023 playoffs, with the Knicks knocking out the higher-seeded Cavs in five behind a young Brunson taking over. The current series is a much different beast, with Cleveland holding a better top-to-bottom roster and New York holding the backcourt advantage. Whoever wins the Harden vs. Brunson minutes battle wins the series. Game 1 told you everything you need to know about which side of that matchup is in trouble.
Cleveland Cavaliers vs. New York Knicks Date, Time, and Where to Watch
- Date: Thursday, May 21, 2026
- Time: 8:00 PM ET
- How to Watch: ESPN, NBA League Pass
Looking for advanced AI predictions and props to enhance your basketball betting? Try out oddschecker+ now on this limited time 7-day free trial!
Cleveland Cavaliers vs. New York Knicks Odds
Click here for complete Cavaliers vs Knicks Odds
Cleveland Cavaliers vs. New York Knicks Team News
Atkinson's biggest decision is what to do with Harden, since pulling him for defense kills the spacing and leaving him in opens the iso buffet for Brunson all over again. Mitchell needs a closer game than he had in Game 1, where he disappeared after halftime and got picked apart on switches by a healthier Anunoby. Mobley and Jarrett Allen continue to be the frontcourt matchup Towns can't body up clean in the post, but the Cavs need both bigs to stay on the floor without giving up their own foul trouble. Sam Merrill and Ty Jerome are the bench shooting variance that either props this team up or buries them, and both went ice cold late in Game 1. Larry Nance Jr. is listed as questionable, which thins out the second unit if he doesn't go.
The Knicks are bringing their full rotation, with Anunoby's hamstring described as "not at full strength" but cleared for full minutes. Brunson's 46-minute Game 1 workload is the only real concern, and head coach Mike Brown will need to figure out how to keep him fresh without giving back the Harden mismatch he found late. Bridges and Anunoby as the perimeter defenders against Mitchell and Harden give this team a defensive ceiling the Cavs haven't seen since round two. Towns has to stay out of foul trouble after picking up his fifth at a brutal time in Game 1. Mitchell Robinson cleaning the glass on second-chance points is the built-in Knicks adjustment that doesn't show up on the box score until you check the offensive rebounding totals at the end of the night.
Prediction: Knicks 113, Cavaliers 104
The market is asking whether Game 1 was a fluke comeback or the start of a real series shift, and the answer probably sits somewhere in between. Cleveland was the better team for 40 minutes of that game, and Mitchell isn't going to disappear two nights in a row at MSG. The Knicks problem for Cleveland is that even when they're getting outplayed in stretches, they have Brunson and a homecourt crowd that ate the entire fourth quarter alive on Tuesday. Game 2 looks more like the slugfest people expected from Game 1 in the first place.
Cleveland comes out punching early and probably leads at the half, but the third quarter is where the Cavs have struggled all postseason. Brunson keeps hunting Harden, the Knicks defense forces a few late turnovers, and MSG turns this into another close-but-not-close finish in the fourth. The Cavs will hang around but walk out 2-0 down in the series.
Cleveland Cavaliers vs. New York Knicks Best Bet
- Knicks -6.5 (+105) Click here to get the best odds at BetMGM Sportsbook
- Jalen Brunson Over 27.5 Points (-108) Click here to get the best odds at DraftKings Sportsbook
Our FairPlay AI likes Knicks -6.5 for Game 2. New York is 19-6 ATS at home this season when favored by 6.5 points or more, which is a brutal sample for a Cleveland team that just blew the easiest cover of their playoff lives. The Cavs sit at 33-47-2 ATS on the year and still have to figure out how to hide Harden in pick-and-roll coverage against the best iso scorer in the conference. The crowd factor at MSG is doing real work here too, especially against a team coming off a loss that probably still hurts to think about. Knicks cover the number even if the game itself stays competitive into the fourth.
It also points to value on Jalen Brunson Over 27.5 Points. Brunson has cleared 30 in four of his last seven playoff games and is averaging 28.4 points per game across the postseason run. The Harden mismatch is the entire ballgame, and the Knicks ran 21 on-ball screens at Harden in the fourth quarter and overtime of Game 1 with Brunson going 8-of-10 on those late shots.
NBA ODDS
Affiliate Disclosure.
We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.
