Colts vs. Rams Prediction, Betting Pick, Latest NFL Odds for Week 4
The Indianapolis Colts have shocked the NFL with a 3-0 start to the Daniel Jones era, and now head on the road to keep it moving against a strong Los Angeles Rams team. Can Indiana Jones and the Colts pick up another road win as a slight underdog? Let's take a look at our Colts vs. Rams prediction and best betting pick for Sunday, September 28th.
OC Staff - September 28, 2025, 9:15 AM EDT
6 Minute ReadColts vs. Rams Prediction: Can Daniel Jones, Colts Continue Winning Magic on Road in LA?
The Indianapolis Colts have been one of the biggest surprises of the young season, racing out to a 3-0 start behind quarterback Daniel Jones. Nicknamed “Indiana Jones” after his hot start in Indy, the veteran has quickly shown command of Shane Steichen’s offense, distributing the ball efficiently while limiting turnovers. The Colts’ ability to control the tempo and finish drives has helped them shock the league, and now they head west as 3.5-point underdogs looking to keep their perfect record intact.
Los Angeles, meanwhile, enters with something to prove. The Rams suffered a gut-wrenching loss to the Philadelphia Eagles last week, watching their potential game-winning field goal get blocked and returned for a touchdown in the final seconds. That dropped them to 2-1, but in reality, they’ve played well enough to be undefeated. With Matthew Stafford still slinging the ball effectively and rookie contributors stepping up, the Rams appear more stable than their banged-up NFC West rivals in San Francisco, giving them a legitimate chance to seize early control of the division.
The betting market has reflected the surge of support for the Colts, as the line opened at +4.5 before being quickly bet down to +3.5. That enthusiasm speaks to Jones’ early impact and the belief that Indianapolis’ momentum can carry over against tougher competition. But the Rams have a balanced roster, home-field advantage, and motivation after last week’s collapse. The question now is whether “Indiana Jones” can keep the magic alive against perhaps his toughest challenge yet, or if the Rams will reassert themselves as one of the NFC’s most dangerous teams.
Looking for advanced AI predictions and props to enhance your NFL betting? Try out oddschecker+ now on this limited time 7-day free trial!
Colts vs. Rams Date, Time, and Where to Watch
- Date: Sunday, September 28, 2025
- Time: 4:05 PM ET
- How to Watch: FOX
Colts vs. Rams Odds
Our AI model has identified a significant betting advantage on the Indianapolis Colts +3.5 for their Week 4 matchup against the Los Angeles Rams. With our proprietary forecast indicating a robust 59.2% probability of the Colts covering, this stands in sharp contrast to the market's implied 52.4%, yielding a substantial 6.8% probability edge and a compelling 13.1% positive expected value.
This analytical conviction is firmly rooted in Indianapolis's impressive early-season performance across critical metrics; they boast a formidable offense ranked 2nd in points scored and 3rd in rushing yards, while simultaneously fielding a top-10 defense that is 9th in points allowed and 7th against both the pass and run. The Colts' exceptional ball security, ranking 1st in turnovers committed, further highlights a disciplined edge that the Rams (12th in turnovers committed) simply don't match. This strong, balanced profile suggests the market is underestimating Indianapolis's capacity to keep this game well within the spread, if not win outright against a less dominant Rams squad.
Click here for the latest Colts vs. Rams Odds
Colts vs. Rams Prediction
The first, and arguably most crucial, confrontation looms for Daniel Jones and the Indianapolis Colts' offense as they face the relentless Los Angeles Rams defense. Jones' historical performance against top-tier pass defenses paints a concerning picture: across five such games, he's managed a dismal 77.7 Passer Rating, averaging just 209.6 passing yards per game, with a 0.8 TD:INT ratio (3 TDs to 4 INTs). This is precisely the kind of challenge the Rams' defense, ranked #1 in the league for pass rush (sacks), is built to exploit.
While the Rams are 14th in QB Rating Allowed, their elite pass rush will undoubtedly amplify the pressure on Jones, forcing quick decisions and potentially leading to turnovers. The narrative here is clear: can Jones elevate his game against an overwhelming pass rush, or will his historical struggles continue, effectively stifling the Colts' aerial attack before it can even begin?
Shifting to the other side of the ball, the Rams' ground game, spearheaded by Kyren Williams, appears poised for a colossal day against the Colts' suspect run defense. Indianapolis ranks a woeful 26th in Rush Yards/Carry Allowed, signaling a significant vulnerability. Williams is projected for 18.4 carries and 81.0 rushing yards, a figure that becomes even more tantalizing when considering the opposing defense.
This isn't just a favorable matchup; it's a golden opportunity for the Rams to establish dominance at the line of scrimmage, control the clock, and set up play-action passes. The data screams opportunity, with our model finding significant positive expected value on Kyren Williams to go Over 70.5 Rushing Yards, presenting a robust 36.7% EV. This indicates a high probability of Williams not only meeting but exceeding his projection, exploiting a clear weakness in the Colts' defensive scheme.
Finally, while not a mismatch of similar magnitude, the duel between Matthew Stafford and the Colts' 10th-ranked pass defense will be a critical test of offensive execution. Stafford's historical splits against top-10 pass defenses are impressive, boasting a 98.2 Passer Rating, 258.4 Pass YPG, and a robust 3.8 TD:INT ratio (15 TDs to 4 INTs) over seven games. This suggests that even against a strong secondary, Stafford possesses the acumen and arm talent to navigate the challenge.
However, the Colts' pass rush is only average (16th in sacks), which bodes well for Stafford having time in the pocket. The success of Kyren Williams on the ground will be directly intertwined with Stafford's effectiveness; if Williams forces the Colts to commit more defenders to the box, it could open up valuable one-on-one opportunities for receivers like Puka Nacua (projected for 7.9 receptions, 97.8 yards, and a positive EV prop on his over 90.5 receiving yards).
Ultimately, the most decisive factor in this contest will hinge on the Colts' ability to protect Daniel Jones and mitigate the relentless pressure from the Rams' #1 ranked pass rush. If Jones falters under duress, as his historical data against elite pass defenses suggests he might, it will severely limit the Colts' offensive capabilities and put immense strain on their defense, especially if Kyren Williams is running wild against their weak run front. The Rams' defensive dominance at the point of attack against Jones is the true lynchpin of this game.
Colts vs. Rams Pick
- Pick: Colts +3.5 (-110) Click here to get these best odds on DraftKings Sportsbook
More NFL Odds
Affiliate Disclosure.
We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.
