Aaron Rodgers Retirement Odds: 70% Chance Rodgers Retires Before 2026 Season After Tomlin Departure
After the Steelers's loss to the Texans in the Wild Card Round, it has been confirmed Aaron Rodgers will be a free agent again. Now, rumors have been abound whether the former Super Bowl Champion and future HOF quarterback will return for another year or hang up the cleats.
Jack Borovitz - January 17, 2026, 6:30 PM EST
5 Minute ReadAaron Rodgers Retirement Odds: 70% Chance Rodgers Retires Before 2026 Season After Tomlin Departure
The Aaron Rodgers retirement saga has taken another turn following Mike Tomlin's surprise resignation from the Pittsburgh Steelers. After the market dropped to near coin-flip territory when Rodgers left the door open post-playoff loss, the odds have rebounded sharply to 70 percent as the reality of his situation becomes clear. The 42-year-old quarterback is now facing the end of his 21-year career without the coach who convinced him to play one more season.
Rodgers signed with Pittsburgh in June 2025 explicitly to play for Tomlin, telling reporters at the time he was "pretty sure this is it" about playing just one year. When Tomlin stepped down Tuesday, the day after the Steelers' 30-6 wild card loss to the Texans, that plan appeared sealed. Steelers president Art Rooney II confirmed what the market already suspected, telling reporters that Rodgers' future would most likely be affected by Tomlin's departure since the quarterback came to Pittsburgh specifically to play for him.
The betting public initially priced retirement at 84-90 percent in the immediate aftermath of the playoff loss, when Rodgers threw 146 yards with no touchdowns and two turnovers that were returned for scores, including a pick-six on what could be his final NFL pass. But when he avoided giving a definitive answer in his postgame press conference, saying he wouldn't make any emotional decisions and would get away to have the right conversations, the market reacted. The odds dropped as low as the mid-40s as bettors interpreted his noncommittal stance as keeping the door open for a 22nd season.
Since then, reality has reasserted itself. Tomlin's exit eliminates the primary reason Rodgers chose Pittsburgh, and reports indicate he's not expected to return to the Steelers. The Vikings and Giants have been floated as potential destinations, but at 42 years old with a legacy already cemented as a four-time MVP and Super Bowl champion, the path forward looks uncertain at best. The emotional scene of Rodgers sobbing in the team meeting room, repeatedly apologizing to Tomlin through tears, suggests the finality of the moment isn't lost on him.
With over $37,000 already traded on Kalshi, bettors are making their call on whether the future Hall of Famer walks away now or attempts to extend his career into a 22nd season. The market at 70 percent reflects the growing consensus that this is the end, but the 30 percent chance he returns keeps things interesting for anyone willing to bet on one more chapter.
Bet on Aaron Rodgers's Retirement with Kalshi Here
Click here to see more NFL Odds
Aaron Rodgers Retirement Odds Breakdown
Retires Before 2026-2027 Season: 70%
The market has settled on retirement as the most likely outcome after weeks of uncertainty. The combination of age, declining performance, and Tomlin's departure creates a natural exit point. Rodgers told reporters in June he was "pretty sure" his one-year Steelers deal would be his last, and nothing about the playoff loss or its aftermath suggests a change of heart. He finished the postseason with two turnovers returned for touchdowns in a 30-6 defeat, a rough final image for a career defined by clutch moments and MVP-caliber play.
Tomlin's resignation the next day removed the primary reason Rodgers chose Pittsburgh over retirement in the first place. Rooney's comments about Rodgers specifically joining to play for Tomlin underscore that reality. The quarterback's emotional reaction in the team meeting, sobbing and repeatedly apologizing to Tomlin, reads more like a goodbye than someone planning to return. At 70 cents for Yes shares, the market is pricing in the end of an era with conviction, though not certainty.
More NFL Odds
Affiliate Disclosure.
We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.
