Cardinals vs. Colts Prediction, Betting Pick, Latest NFL Odds for Week 6
The Indianapolis Colts are red-hot heading into Week 6, and now get to go against a backup QB in Jacoby Brissett for the Cardinals. Can Daniel Jones and the Colts continue to dominate? Let's take a look at our Cardinals vs. Colts prediction for Week 6.
OC Staff - October 12, 2025, 10:20 AM EDT
6 Minute ReadCardinals vs. Colts Prediction: Can Jacoby Brissett Carry Cardinals in Kyler Murray's Absence?
The Arizona Cardinals are limping into Week 6 after another crushing defeat, and now things get even tougher as they head to Indianapolis without Kyler Murray. The former No. 1 pick suffered a foot injury that will sideline him for multiple weeks, forcing veteran Jacoby Brissett into the starting role for the first time this season. Brissett will make his debut with Arizona against his former team, and while his experience provides some stability, the Cardinals’ offense remains one of the league’s least efficient units. They rank 23rd in total offense and have yet to score more than three touchdowns in any game this year, a troubling trend that continued in last week’s blown 4th-quarter collapse against Tennessee.
Meanwhile, the Indianapolis Colts are rolling at 4-1 and are quickly becoming one of the AFC’s most balanced teams. Quarterback Daniel Jones has quietly played his best football since arriving in Indianapolis, managing the game well behind a strong offensive line and leaning on running back Jonathan Taylor, who’s averaging over 5 yards per carry in his last three outings. The defense has also stepped up in big moments, forcing timely turnovers that helped seal consecutive wins over the Texans and Raiders.
The spread has ballooned from Colts -7 to -9.5 following the Murray news, and for good reason. Arizona has struggled to finish games, and now with a new quarterback stepping in, it’s hard to see them turning things around against one of the NFL’s hottest teams. The Colts have the edge in nearly every area and should have no problem controlling this matchup from start to finish.
Looking for advanced AI predictions and props to enhance your NFL betting? Try out oddschecker+ now on this limited time 7-day free trial!
Cardinals vs. Colts Date, Time, and Where to Watch
- Date: Sunday, October 12, 2025
- Time: 1:00 PM ET
- How to Watch: FOX
Cardinals vs. Colts Odds
Click here for the latest Cardinals vs. Colts Odds
Cardinals vs. Colts Prediction
he Cardinals' hopes of an upset largely hinge on quarterback Jacoby Brissett navigating one of the league's most formidable pass defenses. Brissett's projection for the game is a modest 16 completions on 25 attempts for 158.7 yards and 0.5 interceptions. This conservative outlook is further underscored by his historical performance against top-10 pass defenses, where in his single recorded game, he posted a 83.7 Passer Rating and a mere 149.0 passing yards. He now faces a Colts unit ranked 8th in the league for QB Rating Allowed and an impressive 6th in pass rush (sacks). This combination of stifling coverage and relentless pressure creates an arduous environment for any quarterback, let alone one with Brissett's limited statistical output. The data strongly suggests a challenging afternoon for Brissett.
Given the Colts' prowess, particularly in collapsing the pocket and disrupting passing lanes, the model identifies a substantial gap to exploit on the prop market: "Under 207.5 Passing Yards" for Jacoby Brissett at 1.91 (-110) odds. This proposition carries a remarkable Expected Value (EV) of 39.1%, highlighting a massive, almost unprecedented edge for bettors. The narrative here is clear: the Colts' defense is poised to severely limit Brissett's aerial attack, potentially forcing the Cardinals to alter their offensive philosophy.
On the other side of the ball, Colts quarterback Daniel Jones faces a challenging, though perhaps less overwhelming, test against the Cardinals' defense. Jones projects for 22 completions on 31 attempts, 240.1 yards, and 0.6 interceptions. While Jones is often lauded for his dual-threat capabilities, the provided data focuses solely on his passing against a Cardinals defense that ranks 7th in the league for QB Rating Allowed, indicating their own strength in defending the pass.
However, Arizona's pass rush, ranked 20th, is significantly less imposing than Indianapolis', which could offer Jones more time in the pocket. Intriguingly, Jones' historical splits against top-10 pass defenses paint a surprisingly resilient picture: across three games, he boasts a solid 98.0 Passer Rating, averaging 224.0 passing yards, with 3 total touchdowns and zero interceptions. This suggests that despite the Cardinals' strong pass defense, Jones has demonstrated an ability to perform competently against elite units. The battle here isn't necessarily about Jones struggling, but rather whether the Cardinals' secondary can contain him enough to keep their struggling offense in the game. Without the threat of an elite pass rush, Jones might find opportunities to exploit the Cardinals' coverage and keep the Colts' offense rolling.
While the quarterback matchups dominate the headlines, a subtle yet significant clash looms in the Cardinals' ground game. Running back Emari Demercado, with a projected 2.7 attempts for 12.7 yards, might seem inconsequential on paper. However, the Colts' run defense ranks 22nd in the league in Rush Yards/Carry allowed, indicating a noticeable vulnerability on the ground. This juxtaposition of a struggling Cardinals run game and a soft Colts run defense creates a fascinating market inefficiency.
Despite Demercado's low projection, our model identifies a strong opportunity on the prop market: "Over 12.5 Rushing Yards" for Emari Demercado at 1.83 (-120) odds. This prop carries a significant edge with an Expected Value of 4.7%. If the Cardinals are forced to lean on the run due to Brissett's struggles against the Colts' elite pass defense, Demercado could see increased volume, and against a porous run defense, he might surprise many by surpassing his modest projection. This highlights a critical strategic point: if Arizona wants to alleviate pressure on Brissett, they must establish some semblance of a run game, and this matchup against the Colts' interior presents their best chance.
Ultimately, the most decisive factor in this contest will be how Jacoby Brissett and the Cardinals' passing game cope with the relentless pressure and stifling coverage of the Colts' 8th-ranked pass defense and 6th-ranked pass rush. While Daniel Jones has shown an ability to perform against strong secondaries, the Cardinals' offensive struggles, exacerbated by their quarterback's historical difficulties in such matchups, suggest a long afternoon for Arizona. If the Colts' defense can replicate the oppressive environment forecasted by Brissett's projections and historical data, it will be incredibly difficult for the Cardinals to keep pace, making the Colts' defensive dominance over Brissett the single most pivotal battle.
Cardinals vs. Colts Pick
- Pick: Over 46.5 Total Points (-110) Click here to get these best odds on DraftKings Sportsbook
More NFL Odds
Affiliate Disclosure.
We are not a gambling or betting operator, but we receive a commission from these companies when we advertise their brands and refer customers to them (affiliate marketing). We provide information, odds information and links to websites of these companies. Some of the information made available on our site may be positioned as a result of a commission paid to us by a third party. We do not take or place bets/transactions and any information on Our Products is provided for entertainment purposes only.
